Trends

72 GTA 6 Reviews Analyzed, Claim the Game Deserved 92.8, Not 99

72 GTA 6 Reviews Analyzed, Claim the Game Deserved 92.8, Not 99

GTA 6 reviews propelled the game to an unprecedented 99 on Metacritic, but one player decided to examine them item by item and asserts that the score does not reflect what the outlets themselves wrote, because after analyzing 72 full reviews he found that 50 mention performance issues, with drops of up to 20 FPS on PS5, and that many of the ones that gave it a 10 critique its story, pacing, or controls. With those critiques he built his own calculation and arrived at a controversial conclusion, because according to his analysis, published on X, the game deserved a 92.8 rather than the 98.6 average that the published scores total.

The author clarifies that GTA 6 seems like a good game to him and that he is not trying to deny its quality, but rather to question why so many media outlets gave it a perfect score while describing significant flaws in their own text, something he argues reveals an industry pressuring fragile journalism in favor of “false metrics.” His post sparked a heated debate on launch day, just as many players shared FPS drops and bugs on social media, and it reopens an old discussion about what a 10 really means in a video game review.

What the GTA 6 Reviews Analysis Found

An analysis of 72 GTA 6 reviews calculates that, according to its own critiques, the game deserved a 92.8

As he explains, he began by reading the reviews from IGN, The Guardian, GameRant, and GamesRadar, and then gathered 72 full reviews into a file, asked an artificial intelligence to summarize them, and checked each claim by visiting each media’s site. The most recurring issue is performance, mentioned by 50 of the 72 outlets, which recorded frame-rate drops of up to 20 FPS on PS5 and not only in the busiest areas, something that aligns with what Digital Foundry found, which saw GTA 6 dipping to 23 FPS on PS5.

Next come criticisms of the story, in 40 reviews, and of the pacing, in 25, with comments calling Jason dull and describing a plot that starts very slow, drags in the middle, and rushes to the end, in addition to being predictable and forcing players to grind money or reputation. Another 25 reviews complain about movement and combat, which are described as clumsy and button-mashing, with controls that sometimes trigger actions different from what the player intended.

There are also complaints about missing features, such as not being able to buy properties or businesses, the absence of casino mini-games, ruckuses or tennis, and that missions cannot be replayed. A smaller group, comprising 15 reviews, criticizes the game for being too easy at times, because it allows skipping missions if you die repeatedly, and others mention that some content and certain locations are blocked in the Ultimate Edition.

What the outlets that gave it a perfect score wrote

To back up his accusation, the author cited excerpts from GTA 6 reviews with top scores that describe problems in the game:

  • The Guardian (5/5) “This can be a frustrating game at times, unpredictable, laborious, cumbersome, and occasionally unfair.”
  • SirusGaming (10/10) “Rockstar has retained some of the clumsy, rigid controls,” and adds that the frame rate “dropped down to as low as 26 FPS.”
  • GamingBolt (10/10) “The weapons still don’t feel great to control, lacking a weighty sense of heft.”
  • CD-Action (10/10) Mentions floating objects and odd shadows, that “no version includes a Performance mode” and that on base PS5 the game “does not always maintain 30 FPS.”
  • MMORPG.com (10/10) The times between main missions “sometimes felt a little too long.”
  • GamesRadar (10/10) The police pursuit system “can fluctuate between being a bit frustrating and totally thrilling.”

How the 92.8 was calculated and why it isn’t an official score

With those critiques, the author tallied 582 negative points across the 72 GTA 6 reviews and assigned them weights according to how serious he considered each outlet’s gripe, so a major issue is worth triple and a minor one half. He then applied a weighted scheme to each type of problem and adjusted the calculation so that the six reviews that gave it a 9 out of 10 would average exactly 90. According to his chart, the biggest discrepancy is in CD-Action, which gave it a perfect 100 but, based on its own criticisms, would sit around 78; while The Guardian would drop to 95 and IGN to 97.4.

Type of critique Weight
Main gameplay 1.5
Severe bugs 1.5
Performance 1.2
Story and script 1.2
Pacing and stalls 1.0
Difficulty and AI 0.8
Realism friction 0.7
Missing features 0.6
Iteration rather than innovation 0.6
Monetization and price 0.6
Cosmetic errors 0.5
Tone and content 0.5
Translation and accessibility 0.5
Gráfico original del análisis de 72 reseñas de GTA 6, con la nota publicada de cada medio y la nota implícita en sus críticas
Graphic published by the author of the analysis, showing each media’s published score and the score implied by their critiques

The result was a 92.8, a score that remains very high, as the author himself recognizes, but is far from the 99 that set GTA 6 on par with Zelda Ocarina of Time and crowned it the best game in history according to critics. It should be noted, because the weights were defined by him, he used AI to summarize the reviews, and a single review mentioning a flaw does not automatically mean its score is inflated, since a media outlet can acknowledge problems and still consider the game overall to be exceptional.

Still, his approach resonates with what many players feel when comparing GTA 6’s reviews to what they see on launch day, and his closing remarks encapsulate the debate, because he says that “one should be able to have objective and impartial opinions, and still love something,” and he gives as an example that one of his favorite games reads like a 7 out of 10, because his personal experience “should not be reflected in a number.”

Image

Written by

John Kavinsky

John Kavinsky covers Grow a Garden recipes, updates and practical gameplay tips for the site.

Published November 21, 2026

Back to Trends