Tim Sweeney, the head of Epic Games, which also owns the Epic Games Store, the main competitor to Steam, has repeatedly criticized Valve over Steam’s AI tag, a rule that requires developers to include a visible notice whenever a video game contains content generated with artificial intelligence, and in recent months he has pressed the issue with increasingly harsh criticisms, while Gabe Newell, Valve’s co-founder and director, has not responded to any of them.
In a recent interview in which he also discussed Steam’s AI notice, Sweeney asserted that large studios will be transformed entirely by AI, and that teams that do not adopt it will fall behind and become unviable compared to their peers, although he left independent developers out, where according to him there will always be specializations and niches, and he declared his opposition to any law in the United States that would limit its use in game development, because that would give an advantage to other countries that do adopt it.
The clash with public pressure and the rejection of Steam’s AI tags
To back his stance, Sweeney argues that, if a team can make the same game four times more efficiently than another, and soon ten times more efficiently, there is no way to compete in the traditional manner, and that no developer has profit margins of between 75% and 95% that they can risk by not being as productive as possible, a figure of his that is not data-based but reflects his view as the head of a company that makes engines and tools for developers.
His stance comes amid strong pushback against AI in games from players, voice actors, artists, and independent developers, and a GDC report noted that 55% of those surveyed believe that AI has a negative impact on the industry, a figure that contrasts with Sweeney’s enthusiasm.
According to him, there is a resistance movement against AI that tries to press developers not to adopt it, attacking people and filling projects with bad reviews, and that is why he seeks for more creators to hear his opinion and for companies to use the technology to the fullest, because he sees it as a matter of survival for the entire industry.
Regarding Steam’s AI notice, Sweeney, who had already called Valve’s policy abominable, senseless, and politically motivated, now described it as toxic, and when the interviewer suggested that the notice exists to inform players, he replied that he doesn’t believe that at all, since to know the quality, scope, and entertainment of a game there already exists the user review system.
Furthermore, he argues that good and bad games can be made with AI as well as without it, and the same applies to any engine, development tool, methodology, country of origin, or team, so associating AI with bad games is unfair to developers who use it to make good games, which he described as a “guilt by association” that all developers should reject.
The Epic director added that Steam’s AI notice is used toxically by those who are against AI to damage the reputation of developers and the viability of their projects, and that for him the technology can be both a positive and a negative force, but Valve’s mandatory notice functions as a judgment on all technology and not on each game.
The silence of executives and the harsh response from the Steam ecosystem
So far, Newell hasn’t responded to Sweeney’s criticisms, but Chet Faliszek, a prominent former Valve developer, did, in a YouTube video where he described his stance as “AI psychosis.”
Faliszek also said that Sweeney treats all players like children and advised him to act for a moment like a player and ask what they’d like to know about a game before buying it.
The discussion remains open, with opposing views on whether Steam’s AI tag helps inform players or harms developers who use AI, with the peculiarity that the person most critical is the owner of a store that competes with Steam, and a similar debate about what players get in digital format arose after the announcement of the end of physical PlayStation discs.

